Critical Appraisal Of Quantitative Research. Abstract. The abstract consisted of one paragraph, total of ten sentences, which includes the purpose, design, sampling, and results. Researchers expanded on results but did not include conclusion. Relevant information such as sample size, study design, measure outcomes, and results were included Feb 09, · The steps for critical appraisal of quantitative studies, focused on rigor, design validity, quality, and meaning of findings, are detailed, and an example of a critical appraisal of a published quantitative study is provided. The chapter concludes with the critical appraisal process for qualitative studies and an example of a critical Jan 18, · Research Critique, Part 1 Grand Canyon University: NUR V March 15, Introduction Critical appraisal of a research study demonstrates an understanding of the research study being conducted. This paper will review a qualitative research study designed to explore the lived experience of lay presence during adult cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in primary and
Example of a Critical Appraisal Research Paper - Words
The title of the article: Drug administration errors: a study into the factors underlying the occurrence and reporting of drug errors in a district general hospital.
The study identifies themes underlying occurrence and reporting of errors in drug administration. The title reflects the theme of the survey. Was the problem clearly stated with relevant background and justification critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research the study? The problem is not well stated but the background information provided justifies the need for the study; that is, previous research shows that there are errors in drug administration, but they do not explain the reasons.
Is the majority of the review of literature current? References listed at the end of the article less than ten years old from date of publication unless a classic study. Most of the references that the researcher use as sources of data are up to date since they were published less than ten years from the time of publication hence provide pertinent information. The research questions are; what are the most common factors for nurses during drug administration?
What are the outcomes of drug administration errors? Are there operational definitions or terms defined or that clarify the topic studied in the article? There are no defined operational terms in this study. The operational definitions help in the preserving unambiguous empirical testability of a problem. What is the research design descriptive, experimental, etc. and how does it support the type of study? The researcher used experimental design which supports the quantitative study by using statistical ways of solving questions.
The sample was nurse managers and trained nurses. Data was collected by use of questionnaires and interviews. The Inclusion or exclusion criteria used randomly. Every nurse who was between class C and G had equal chances of participation. Describe if and how the subjects protected from harm and were there appropriate approval granted and by whom?
The researcher ensured the protection of the respondent by using hand written notes to collect data critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research respondents since some felt that tape recording was too threatening.
Nurses who perform drug errors feel guilty and lose clinical confidence. The nurse teachers feel a failure that the education process did not prevent the occurrence of a mistake. How were tables and graphs used to actually to describe the findings? The tables and graphs are self-explanatory, clear, informative titles and data were represented in explicit appropriate categories.
Does the discussion section state whether the findings from this study support or refute previous studies? The results do not state any rebuttal or support to studies made before this study. The author just gives recommendations. The author recommends nurses and managers be given a correct definition of drug errors. There should also be recognition and monitoring of the errors. Additionally, the author suggests promotion of accurate reporting, support, and education.
Appraise the online article on medication administration by Baker and answer the questions below. It describes the autonomy that nurses take over drug administration.
These are the rules that the nurses draft outside the norms of drug administration. Was the problem clearly stated with pertinent background and justification for the study? The stating of the problem was evident with relevant context; having worked as a critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research Baker is aware of how nurses behave at work by reporting fewer errors or not following what the institution policies ask them to.
This information is what is exemplified in the whole study, thus justifying the problem. References listed at the end of the article less than ten years old from date of publication unless classic study and do the references cited to support the study? Most of the data sources used for the survey are outdated since they were more than 10 years old from the date of publication.
Some of the references cited to support the study while some are irrelevant. There are no defined operational definitions in this study. Qualitative descriptive research design; research problems become the research questions drawn from previous studies which leave gaps. Who was the sample, how was data collected and were there inclusion or exclusions described? Nurses in one large provincial hospital were the sample and the method of data collection was participant observation.
There were no inclusion or exclusion criteria outlined in the study. Describe if and how the subjects protected from harm and if there was the appropriate approval granted and by whom? Did the methodology use one of the researchers as the instrument to interview or observe the participants?
The methodology ethnomethodology used as a tool to understand the problem at hand through observation and to interview the respondents. The sample size was three wards in a large provincial critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research hospital. This sample size was inadequate since a large hospital has many wards with many nurses critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research three wards would not be a representative of the whole.
The responses were divided into three categories; the first set results logic, the second was criteria for redefining errors, and the third one was the one entailing serendipitous findings. The findings were that the nurses were autonomous over what real errors mean. The research questions were answered about bringing an understanding of how nurses define or redefine medication error. Does the discussion state whether the findings from this study support or refute previous;studies?
Yes, critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research, they are because the present discussion ideas in a general perspective based on the research. The researcher recommends more contributions by nurses to official strategic rules for the administration of error to be able to differentiate between time-critical and no-time-critical medications.
Skip to content Critical appraisal example Author slast name and first initial: Gladstone J. Year of publication: The title of the article: Drug administration errors: a study into the factors underlying the occurrence and reporting of drug errors in a district general hospital. Journal name: Journal of advanced nursing Journal page number: Appraise article on medication administration by Gladstone and answer the following questions Discuss the following in sentencesDo not respond with just yes or no.
How does the title of the research accurately describe what the study is about? References listed at the end of the article less than ten years old from date of publication unless a classic study Most of the references that the researcher use as sources of data are up to date since they were published less than ten years from the time of publication hence provide pertinent information, critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research. Who was the sample, how was data collected?
Was there inclusion or exclusion criteria described to be a part of this sample? What were the findings? Were the research questions answered? What were statistical tests used to analyze the data? The statistical tests used are pie charts, bar graphs, and tables. Are generalizations made to other populations based on the findings from this study?
Yes, they are because the present discussion ideas in a general perspective based on the study. Critical Appraisal of Qualitative Research Article Author slast name and first initial: Baker H. Year of publication: Title of article: Rules outside the rules for administration of medication Journal name: Journal of nursing scholarship Journal page numbers: Appraise the online article on medication administration by Baker and answer the questions below.
Discuss the following questions in sentences. Do not respond with just yes or no. These are the rules that the nurses draft outside the norms of drug administration 2, critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research. Are there operational definitions critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research terms defined and how do they clarify the study?
Critical appraisal of research 5. What is the research design and how does it support a qualitative study? How large was the sample and how was size determined and was it an adequate sample size? Critical appraisal of research article example How were data analyzed? The researcher provided feedback for the data collected.
Were the descriptions or responses bracketed, categorized or divided in anyway? The discussion just elaborates the findings of the survey, critical appraisal example essay nursing quantitative research. Are generalizations made to other populations based on the research from this study? Previous Post Previous.
Next Post Next.
Critical Appraisal of the Nursing Literature
, time: 6:17Critical Appraisal of Quantitative and Qualitative Research for Nursing Practice | Nurse Key
This essay evaluates a quantitative research article which has relevance to nursing practice, because it deals with a chronic condition and one which is prevalent in worldwide populations. The author will review Tangkawanich et al ( p ) ‘Causal model of health: health-related quality of life in people living with HIV/AIDS in the northern region of Thailand.’ Critical Appraisal Of Research Articles Abstract This Paper provides a critical appraisal of two scholarly articles that have been presented on research methods. The aspects governing the qualitative research method have been dealt with in an article analyzing qualitative research by J.V. Appleton, while the quantitative research method was Jan 18, · Research Critique, Part 1 Grand Canyon University: NUR V March 15, Introduction Critical appraisal of a research study demonstrates an understanding of the research study being conducted. This paper will review a qualitative research study designed to explore the lived experience of lay presence during adult cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in primary and
No comments:
Post a Comment